The Pitch from Simon Jordan
At the time of writing, Aston Villa manager Unai Emery is reportedly in talks over a new contract with the club. There are perfectly good reasons for him to stay. He has done a remarkable job, and if Villa can give him the platform to take the next step, why shouldn’t he do it there?
But amid all the discussion about Manchester United and potential managerial candidates, there is a broader argument worth challenging: that a successful manager should steer clear of a bigger club because the job comes with bigger problems.
Michael Carrick remains in charge at United. I’m not appointing his successor or touting Emery for his position. But if United – or a club of comparable stature – were looking for a manager, why should somebody with the capability and ambition automatically be advised to run a mile?
The argument is that Emery has a club built around him at Villa, whereas a bigger club might offer him bigger problems. Perhaps. But bigger problems are not the same thing as a smaller opportunity.
Managers know who the biggest clubs are. History, scale and the chance to compete at the very top still mean something to ambitious football people. They don’t look at a difficult job and automatically conclude that somebody else should do it. They back themselves to succeed where others have failed.
A player arriving at a club with an established international in his position doesn’t necessarily think he’s being signed to keep the bench warm. He thinks he’ll take the other bloke’s place. Managers are no different.
Villa have ambitious owners and Emery has done a remarkable job, but an owner’s willingness to spend is not the same as permission to spend. You can have the money and the appetite, and still find the financial rules putting a ceiling on what you can do.
That is why the attraction of a bigger club cannot simply be dismissed as vanity. It can give a manager the means to achieve something that is much harder elsewhere, however supportive his existing employers might be.
I’m also entirely unconvinced by this notion that Emery controls everything at Villa but would somehow become a passenger at a bigger club.
Does he sign the cheques? Set the budget? Negotiate every contract? Of course he doesn’t. He works within a framework in which he has significant influence. That is what managers do. They are not either running the entire business or just putting the cones out. Football isn’t that simple.
That’s the kick-off. Members get the full ninety.
Simon’s only just getting going. Members get the rest of The Pitch, Piers and Simon’s calls on the weekend’s big games, and this week’s bonus video.
Continue as a memberAlready a subscriber? Sign in


