The Pitch from Simon Jordan
Whenever a manager is under pressure, we get the same argument. Ten games is too few. Fifteen isn’t enough. Give him until Christmas.
Manchester United have now sacked Michael Carrick, with the club in the Premier League’s relegation zone after ten games. In announcing his departure, United said a change was necessary “in order to achieve our ambitions”.
Crystal Palace have also confirmed Pierre Sage’s dismissal. Both clubs have now acted on the question every owner eventually has to answer: is the man in charge capable of putting things right?
Reaching that judgement requires more thought than looking at the league table or joining the latest managerial sack race.
During my time as Palace’s owner, my instinct was to support the manager. He was my appointment, my champion. If I had done my job properly recruiting him, I wanted to back him – not bow to the background noise.
But you have to know what you are looking at.
You should know the capabilities of your squad, what the manager inherited, and whether you have given him the resources to meet your expectations. You should hear his explanation for the problems and judge whether it bears any relationship to what you are watching.
At Palace, European commitments and the sale of important players matter. You cannot keep selling your best players, replace them with players who are not at the same level, and expect the same standards while adding another competition.
Some of those problems are of your own making. Take some responsibility.
But once you have accounted for the legitimate difficulties, is the team still underperforming? And is this manager capable of providing the solution?
I have got that judgement wrong myself.
When I appointed Peter Taylor at Palace, I had reservations. I thought he was a good coach but questioned whether he was the manager we needed. But he was an old Palace favourite, and I talked myself into thinking perhaps my reservations were wrong.
Within a fortnight, things were bothering me. Yet I let it drift for a year.
The football was dull, the results were mediocre and the supporters were ambivalent. We were becoming a mid-table Championship side.
Eventually, I thought: this is time wasted. We’re not losing anything, but we’re damn sure not gaining anything.
I kept hoping it would come right. And hope is the thing that will kill you.
I dismissed him with a line I’ve always rather liked: “I don’t know how we’ll get along without you, but from Monday we’re going to try.”
That’s the kick-off. Members get the full ninety.
Simon’s only just getting going. Members get the rest of The Pitch, Piers and Simon’s calls on the weekend’s big games, and this week’s bonus video.
Continue as a memberAlready a subscriber? Sign in


