Don’t forget to scroll all the way down for EXCLUSIVE Bonus Content!
The Past is Not Past
As Russia increasingly threatens NATO, is the United Kingdom ready for war?
The question has been debated in the British Parliament. In this week’s episode, it’s the turn of Bianca and Tim to explore it. As you have come to expect by now, they don’t stick to the headlines and re-hash the same old arguments about spending 3% of GDP on defence by 2030.
Instead, Bianca and Tim go back in time to understand exactly what it takes to defend the British Realm – and how that has changed over the course of history.
Britain’s defence has always been inexorably linked to its geography. That is not surprising: every country’s military strategy is the result of where it is on the map – and how easy it is for others to invade. As Napoleon once said, “the policy of a state lies in its geography.” If you want to learn more about why that is, pick up the book Prisoners of Geography by a certain Tim Marshall.
Britain, of course, is an island with no external land borders. That made it a real challenge to invade. That doesn’t mean no one succeeded, though.
“1066 is often called the last successful invasion of England, but that only holds if you mean conquest by a foreign power,” Bianca explains. “Armies crossed the sea and took the crown several times afterwards: Isabella and Roger Mortimer in 1326, Henry Bolingbroke in 1399, Edward IV in 1471, Henry Tudor in 1485 and William of Orange in 1688. Prince Louis of France held London for over a year in 1216 before withdrawing. Most were English power struggles fought with foreign help. 1688 is the outlier: a foreign ruler with a foreign army, whose invitation from a handful of English grandees some historians see as cover for a Dutch strategic gamble.”
Still, Britain was more unassailable than other countries in Europe. This state of insularity has always occupied a central role in the British imagination. In his play Richard II (1595), William Shakespeare’s John of Gaunt calls England “a precious stone set in a silver sea”. That sea served “as a moat defensive to a house”. This idea of the sea as a moat is a founding myth of British island exceptionalism. And like every myth, it has its roots in reality.
For centuries, the Channel did act as a moat. Without a long land frontier to defend, Britain did not need the enormous permanent armies maintained by continental powers.
“That freed money and political attention for the Royal Navy, while the sea also gave Britain the ability to choose where and when to intervene in Europe rather than permanently exposing itself to invasion,” Bianca explains. “Modern military historians describe this combination of insularity, finance and naval power as central to Britain’s distinctive strategy from the late 17th century onwards.”
But the moat only worked if Britain controlled it. An island necessarily relies on importing what it needs. That means that it is protected by the sea and dependent on it at exactly the same time.
Britain’s enemies repeatedly understood this. In the early 19th century, Napoleon (him again) tried to blockade Britain. In both world wars, Germany used U-boats – submarines armed with torpedoes – to sink the merchant ships carrying vital supplies to Britain. It’s for that reason that Winston Churchill’s greatest wartime fear was U-boats.
So how is it different today?
Continued in the members’ edition
Members follow the thread all the way back: the full Past Is Not Past, Bianca and Tim answering readers’ questions, the reading list behind the episode, and this week’s bonus video.
Read the rest as a memberAlready a subscriber? Sign in


